Connect w/ Donna
  • Home
  • About
  • News & Blog
  • Media
  • Brazile & Associates
  • Contact

Home / News / “Chaos and Bashing”

“Chaos and Bashing”

Posted on: 11-2-2015 Posted in: News

From the git-go, the CNBC moderators lost control of the third Republican presidential Debate to the candidates. And it wasn’t hard.

Sen. Ted Cruz wrested a budget question away from CNBC reporter Carl Quintanilla and turned it on him, “The questions asked in this debate illustrate why the American people don’t trust the media,” Cruz lectured, as the audience erupted with applause.

In what was likely a rehearsed moment, Cruz continued to lambast the CNBC panel. “This is not a cage match,” he said. More applause.

Then Sen. Cruz showed total genius — pre-planned or not. Under the guise of attacking the moderators for their questions, Cruz managed to repeat all the unflattering things asked of his opponents: “Donald Trump, are you a comic book villain? Ben Carson, can you do math? John Kasich, will you insult two people over here? Marco Rubio, why don’t you resign? Jeb Bush, why have your numbers fallen?”

Applause from the audience. It didn’t stop there.

Sen Marco Rubio led off the media bashing earlier, also to applause. “The Democrats have the ultimate super PAC,” he said. “It’s called the mainstream media.” And, even earlier, Trump had tweeted, “I am now in Colorado looking forward to what I am sure will be a very unfair debate!” Some complained that CNBC moderators were attempting ‘gotcha’ questions. Instead, it looks as if the Republicans executed their own thought-out ‘gotcha’ plan. And it worked….for now.

Before the main debate, there was the so-called ‘undercard debate.’ It’s not clear if anybody won that debate; it’s not clear if anyone really can win it. Face it, the undercard debate looks like the competition they hold for kids during the Super Bowl break. On this undercard debate, social media comments were replete with the word, “painful.”

Senator Lindsey Graham did come away with good marks from most political observers. Mitt Romney even tweeted that Graham deserved to move up to the “big stage.”

Back at the featured debate, the media bashing continued like executing a well-rehearsed football play. Both Cruz and Trump offered their opinion that the Democrats had much easier questions. (The difference was Democrats were asked clear, substantive questions, and didn’t sidestep them).

Reince Priebus, the head of the Republican National Committee, tweeted, “…I’m proud of our team for standing up against the improper and unprofessional display put on by CNBC.”

Backstage, Bush campaign manager Danny Diaz got into what a Politico reporter described as a ‘heated confrontation’ with an CNBC official over the debate format and the lack of speaking time Bush was getting.

Republican commentators were at the ready to reinforce the idea that the media can’t be trusted, which if believed, would give the Republicans the last word on any narrative during the 2016 campaign.

The Republican ‘victim’ mantra did backfire with some. Byron York, chief correspondent for the conservative Washington Examiner, tweeted, “Strong sense in Boulder [that the] debate will be [the] media/CNBC story above all. Words ‘disaster,’ ‘catastrophe’ flying around. Serious blowback for RNC.”

There were many who agreed the moderator’s questions were, well, way too long and winding. Some questions were longer than the answers. It didn’t help that the moderators lost control of the debate from the start, which was late starting by the way. The candidates ruled throughout, bickering, over-talking, and back and forth arguing with the moderators. It was close to chaos.

Huckabee, in his closing remarks, took his own ‘slap’ at CNBC. As for CNBC (who should thank their lucky stars they didn’t provide free access), a spokesman issued a one-line retort: “People who want to be president of the United States should be able to answer tough questions.”

With less than 95 days before the Iowa Caucus, this debate proved once again that some of the candidates are destined to win, and some are simply going to hobble by until the voters put them out of contention. Next to Cruz, Rubio was a star performer. He took on Jeb Bush’s witty criticism of Rubio’s poor attendance record in the Senate, suggesting he was practicing a French three-day work week. But, Rubio had a commanding comeback, “I don’t remember you ever complaining about John McCain’s vote record, and the only reason you’re complaining about mine,” Rubio asserted, was because a Bush strategist suggested attacking him.

Gov Chris Christie appears ready for his moment. If it ever comes. He scored, or roared, playing off a Jeb Bush reference to fantasy football as inappropriate, given all the problems that could be discussed, and bawling out a moderator for interrupting him.

As for former Gov Jeb Bush, it was not a good night. He offered to give “a warm kiss” to any Democrat who will cut spending by $10. Somehow I don’t think that was a phrase that he really wanted to work in there.

Trump and Carson, the leaders, were content to hold their own and not risk their leads in the polls. Carly Fiorina garnered moments before the cameras, but said nothing that people were repeating in the “spin room.”

The takeaway is this—if you’re looking for a presidential candidate who will relentlessly attack the media, you’ve got plenty of choices among the Republicans. The next media thrashing is scheduled for November 10 in Milwaukee. Bring your own popcorn.

About the Author

Donna Brazile
Veteran Democratic political strategist Donna Brazile is an adjunct professor, author, syndicated columnist, television political commentator, Vice Chair of Voter Registration and Participation at the Democratic National Committee, and former interim National Chair of the Democratic National Committee as well as the former chair of the DNC’s Voting Rights Institute.

Recent Blog Posts

  • The Trump impeachment trial and our duty to history
  • Donna Brazile, Michael Steele: These 7 election reforms will safeguard American democracy
  • Peaceful civil rights protests vs. deadly Capitol attack: Which path will we choose?
  • We have made this country what it said it always was — a country for all of us.
  • Republicans and Democrats must unite behind Biden to tackle COVID and other serious problems

Donna on Twitter

Tweets by @donnabrazile

© 2019 Donna Brazile - Brazile & Associates
TwitterStumbleUponRedditDiggdel.icio.usFacebookLinkedIn